I use the 
UNTAPPD app to keep track of each beer I try. I believe it all started when I couldn't remember what brewer's version of Oktoberfest I liked, and which ones I hated. As of today, I have tasted and rated 562 beers. I rate all the beers on a 5 star scale: 3 is average, 3.5 is good, 4 is great, 4.5 is the best I have had. So here is the list:
IPAs and APAs
4.5 stars
- Furious - Surly Brewing Company 
 
- Pliny the Elder - Russian River Brewing Company
 
4 stars
- Pale Ale - Sierra Nevada Brewing Co.
 
- Two Hearted Ale - Bell's Brewery
 
- Unrated Rye IPA - 612 Brew
 
- Abrasive Ale - Surly Brewing Company  
 
- Todd The Axe Man - Surly Brewing Company 
 
- 1349 Pale Ale - Surly Brewing Company
 
- Wet - Surly Brewing Company 
 
- Stone IPA - Stone Brewing
 
- Stone Delicious IPA - Stone Brewing
 
- Stone Enjoy By 10.31.15 - Stone Brewing 
 
- Stone Mocha IPA - Stone Brewing
 
- Fresh Squeezed IPA - Deschutes Brewery
 
- Size 7 - Steel Toe Brewing
 
- Green Bullet IPA - Dangerous Man Brewing Co.
 
- Pinner Throwback IPA - Oskar Blues Brewery
 
- Boneshaker - Amsterdam Brewing Company
 
- Saga IPA - Summit Brewing Company
 
- Hopslam Ale - Bell's Brewery
 
- 30th Anniversary Double IPA - Summit Brewing Company
 
- Wolf Pup Session IPA - Golden Road Brewing
 
- Space Dust IPA - Elysian Brewing Company
 
- Alabaster Woodchuck - Bent Brewstillery
 
- Grapefruit Sculpin - Ballast Point Brewery & Spirits
 
- Rebel Grapefruit IPA - Samuel Adams
 
- Citradelic - New Belgium Brewing Company
 
Ales 
4.5 stars
- Bender - Surly Brewing Company 
 
4 stars
- Fat Tire - New Helgium Brewing Company 
 
- Cacao Bender - Surly Brewing Company 
 
- Coffee Bender - Surly Brewing Company 
 
- Newcastle Brown Ale - John Smith's 
 
- Tour de Fall - New Belgium Brewing Company
 
- Mourning Wood - Local Option Bierwerker
 
- Cold Press Black - Bent Paddle Brewing Co. 
 
- Decadent Dark Chocolate Ale - Atwater Brewery 
 
Sours
4.5 stars
- Pentagram - Surly Brewing Company 
 
- Coolship #2 - Elgood's Brewery
 
- VanderGhinste Oud Bruin - Omer Vander Ghinste Brewery
 
- Roselle - Fair State Brewing Cooperative 
 
 4 stars
-  Saint Dekkera Reserve Sour: Flanders Red - DESTIHL Brewery
 
- Wekken Sour - De Proefbrouwerij
 
- Aunt Sally - Lagunitas Brewing Company
 
 
 
Porters and Stouts
4.5 stars
- Death by Coconut - Oskar Blues Brewery
 
 4 stars
- Vanilla Java Porter - Atwater Brewery
 
- Cutthroat Porter - Odell Brewing Co. 
 
- Guinness Draught - Guinness
 
- Chocolate Milk Stout - Dangerous Man Brewing Co 
 
- Trespass Porter - Jack Pine Brewery
 
- Darkness (2015) - Surly Brewing Company
 
- The Abyss - Deschutes Brewery
 
- Gobias - Oliphant Brewing
 
- Cassian Sunset - Central Water Brewing Company
 
- Cinnamon Rasin Commodore - Ballast Point Brewing & Spirits
 
- 2X Stout - Southern Tier Brewing Company
 
 
Lagers
4.5 stars
- Grain Belt Nordest - August Schell Brewing Company (Grain Belt)
 
 4 stars
- Grain Belt Premium - August Schell Brewing Company (Grain Belt)
 
- First Call - Modist Brewing Company
 
 
 Others
4.5 stars
- Stiegl Radler Grapefruit NaturtrĂ¼b (shandy) - Stieglbrauerei zu Salzburg
 
4 stars
- Strongbow Cider (cider) - Bulmers Cider
 
- Jack-O Traveler Pumpkin Shandy (shandy) - Traveler Beer Co. 
 
- Spencer Trappist Ale (belgian) - Spencer Brewery
 
- The Bennie (bock) - Granite City Food & Brewery
 
- Delirium Tremens (belgian) - Brouwerij Huyghe
 
- Saison (saison) - Brasserie St-Feuillien 
 
- One (belgian) - Surly Brewing Company